Remember when evangelicals would lose their minds over someone saying, “This is my truth”?
They would holler about how this is a “denial of absolute truth”. It was yet another “culture war” thing that wasn’t a thing. A gnat to be strained at while the camel is swallowed whole.
I lived it, so I’m telling you my truth.
The evangelical right claimed that the secular left would deny absolute truth by saying “this is my truth”, as if the truth is different for everyone. This, they would claim, would deny the absolute truth claims of Christianity, which demands our allegiance.
Claiming that saying “my truth” is a denial of facts can only really be done by someone who has never met anyone outside of their own circle. They heard it once in a sermon or read it in a blog and validated it because it upholds their own truth, paradoxically.
When I claim “my truth” and am simply saying that my experiences of facts might be different than your experiences of facts. When I want to hear “your truth”, I want to hear how you experience the world, your parents, your family, your life, and I want to believe you.
I want to believe you because I know that you experience those things differently than I do.
A black man experiences a traffic stop differently than a white man.
A woman experiences a man on a hiking trail differently that I would, as a man.
One sibling might experience their parents differently than other siblings.
Maybe my experience of Reformed churches is different than yours.
It is quite arrogant to assume that your experiences of traffic stops, men on hiking trails and your parents is the absolute norm for all faith and practice for every person in every time frame.
I try to understand that people who stay within the “proper boundaries” and recite the proper theology and have the proper skin color and vote the right way might have a different experience of Reformed churches than I do.
I’ve never fit into a boys club, don’t brew my own beer, don’t like cigars, don’t like endless debates of theological minutiae that makes no difference to how we love our neighbor, and don’t draw within the lines. I ask too many awkward questions.
So I know that I perceive Reformed churches differently than someone who colors in the lines.
But my truth is still my truth. I saw the hatred and fear and covenant breaking first hand.
Some would experience a pastor as kindhearted and jovial. Others, who dared ask a question that he couldn’t answer, might experience him as angry, volatile and a bully.
One might experience a man as friendly and safe. A child who has been raped by that same man might be triggered and shrink away in fear.
The only way that you can know someone is if you understand your biases and your experiences, and truly listen to the truth as they have experienced it. They might even use “my truth” to explain it.
It is not at all their intention to deny the facts of science or the truth claims of religion. They are simply acknowledging that their experience might be different than yours. Their experience is still true.
If you have never experienced being stalked and molested by that particular elder in the church, that doesn’t mean that the elder does NOT stalk and molest people.
You might not experience trafficking and rape as a child by an elder, but he may still be a trafficker and a rapist.
Your parents might be kind and jovial and wise to the whole world and horrible to you. Your truth is still valid and that trauma sticks.
The man in Dahmer’s dungeon would experience Dahmer differently than the clerk would at the supermarket.
Here’s the funny thing that took me far too long to realize. People also experience the Bible the same way. And yes, I believe in absolute truth. I believe in truth and falsehood.
But absolute religious claims as true or false are shaped by our minds. We have to approach God with the humility to say that maybe our biases are wrong, maybe our experiences are shaping our reading so maybe we are approaching the text with a mindset that needs to be changed in order to understand it. This is why we see dimly. We haven’t yet seen him face to face.
When we behold him, we shall be like him, and then and only then will we see clearly.
Beware of anyone who says, “The scripture is clear”, especially if they are using the scripture to own slaves, own women, possess a harem, steal from the poor, lie and worship an idol. If they are using the bible to hate and oppress, and claim that “the scripture is clear”, they are certainly reading bits and pieces through their own prejudices and anger.
For this reason, Christians have always confessed that the power of the Holy Spirit enlightening the heart is necessary for proper understanding. He strips away our biases, he takes the clouded judgment away, and he gives us the humility to listen to those who do not share our experiences.
But we are used to dividing up and hurling anathemas at one another. Hundreds of denominations, each one claiming that their own perceptions are correct and everyone else in the world is wrong.
One thing that “radicalized” me was realizing that God has had millions of people around the world since the beginning. And maybe a tiny, German Reformed denomination of around 3,000 people doesn’t actually have the monopoly on God’s revelation.
And I do believe in truth. But I am also aware of bias and trauma and pathologies.
So hold your opinions loosely. Listen to those with other viewpoints. Understand that you might be wrong about something. And focus on what it means to love your neighbor as yourself.
It seems to me that is what it means to “walk humbly with God.”
Make a one-time donation
Make a monthly donation
Make a yearly donation
Choose an amount
Or enter a custom amount
Your contribution is appreciated.
Your contribution is appreciated.
Your contribution is appreciated.
DonateDonate monthlyDonate yearly